Skip to main content

Super Mario Bros: The Lost Levels

While the series is a little too mainstream for what I originally intended, I realize that I have yet to review a Mario game.  I have tried to stick to the obscure, but at this point I have covered Sonic, Final Fantasy, Madden and any number of popular franchises, so why not.

I still wanted to keep it a little out there though.  Most people have heard of the Lost Levels, but its certainly the black sheep of the old school series.  It’s origin story is probably more well known than the game itself.  This was actually Super Mario Bros. 2 in Japan.  It was deemed “too difficult” for U.S. audiences by Nintendo of America, as it was assumed they weren’t as skilled or patient as Japanese players.  Instead of releasing it stateside, they re-skinned a game called Doki Doki Panic with Mario characters, called it Super Mario Bros 2 and called it a day (which explains why that game is so different from everything else in the series).  It wasn’t until the release of the Super Mario All Stars compilation on the SNES that western audiences saw this game.  (Full disclosure, that’s the version I played.)  

Image result for super mario bros lost levels

But here’s the thing.  It wasn’t necessarily that the game was too hard for western gamers.  Believe me, its hard as all hell, but there were plenty of incredibly difficult games that were released in the U.S.  The problem is that it was waaaaaaaaay too frustrating for Western gamers.  I don’t buy that American gamers aren’t as skilled as our Japanese counterparts, but I would certainly believe we are less patient.  And The Lost Levels absolutely demands an insane amount of patience.

The controls are identical to the original SMB, a jumps, b runs and shoots if applicable, you move and control yourself midair with the d-pad.  The physics are the same, Mario generates momentum when he runs, jumps hire when he bounces off an enemy, etc.  You know the drill, although I guess it wasn’t a given at the time seeing as this was only the second game in the series.  A lot of games that are this infuriating are so because of lousy controls, but that isn’t the case here.  Mario’s control scheme and physics are, were and always will be near-perfect for a 2D platformer.

What does make the game so frustrating is the level design.  This design here isn’t challenging, its downright sadistic.  I know a lot of gamers complained about the poison mushrooms, but that is the least of our worries.  Countless levels have hidden blocks that are placed to make jumping as difficult as possible.  You will think you can make a jump, only to bang your head on a hidden coin block and be forced down into a pit.  At least you got a coin!  Many of the stages are cramped and confined, a huge 180 from the first game.  It’s rarely beneficial to power up, as Super or Fire Mario won’t be able to jump over enemies or clear jumps because their size limits their movement.  I found myself playing small for most of the game, as most of the danger comes from the never ending, instant death pits as opposed to enemies.

And that’s just the start.  Remember all those shortcuts in the first game?  You know, you go down a pipe, grab some coins and then pop back up?  They would either skip to ahead in the level or, worst case scenario, put you right back where you were?  Well, in the Lost Levels, many of them are death traps.  You will find a bonus area, grab your coins and leave, only to find you have popped up from a pipe with nowhere to go but into a pit.  In one instance, I think its in world 3, you will find a secret that takes you to a warp zone.  Those were cool, right?  The problem is that instead of taking you to one of the next few wolds, this one takes you back to the first level of the game.  At least they were generous enough to give you a small pit to suicide yourself down...

And that is the biggest issue here, the constant, never ending, slap-in-the-face beginners traps.  Challenge is great and not every game has to be a zero difficulty walking simulator, but there is a difference between challenge and cheapness.  Stuff like that doesn’t make the game challenging, it makes it cheap.  Cheap games are frustrating.  Part of the reason I started this blog was because I was tired of games that drove me nuts with stuff like that.  I think this is the first time I’ve raged at a game in more than a year, and when I rage at video games, I REALLY rage.  Ask anyone in my Destiny clan.

That being said, I can’t say it wasn’t without its charm.  At the end of the day, it’s still Mario and that’s enough to push it past many of its contemporaries.  Some level design choices are absurd, but there are some inspiring and unique sections too.  I definitely wanted to keep going, no matter how frustrating it got.  I did end up beating the game, but full disclosure, there is no way I would have been able to beat it in one, single 5 life run on the NES.  Super Mario All Stars has a save feature, so you can restart from where you lost all your lives.   This is also the first game to feature Luigi as a separate playable character with his own unique abilities, which is cool.  

I can further justify not taking too many points off because Nintendo went out of its way to let people know how hard the game was.  The Japanese version featured the text “for super players only” on the cover, letting everyone know this wasn’t going to be a walk in the park.  Still, the cramped level design in Lost Levels is needlessly oppressive and each level is packed with cheap, frustrating death traps that are more apt to test your patience than your gaming skills.  A lesser franchise would have been DOA with level design like this, but Mario’s quality makes this worth seeking out for some challenge junkies and completionists.  Casual gamers should stay away.

6/10

Play this if:
You are a patient gamer looking for a challenge
You are a Mario Completionist

Avoid if:
You can't handle cheap deaths
You already have too many broken controllers or holes in your wall

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Alex Kidd in Miracle World

I've been skirting around it for a few years now, but its finally time to add yet another console to the list. A few years ago, I reviewed Alex Kidd in the Enchanted Castle, a Genesis platformer that I didn't really enjoy all that much. I talked a little bit about how Alex Kidd was Sega's mascot before Sonic became a thing and how hyped up I was to give AKITEC a try, having heard so much about the series. That was part of the reason the game fell flat for me, though poor level design and awful boss fights were more than likely the bigger culprits. What I didn't realize at the time was that much of the positive sentiment I had heard about the series had nothing to do with its lone Genesis entry. Instead, much of the positivity was focused on the various entries on Sega's third generation console, a machine that I have been looking for an excuse to play for a long time. For most North American gamers, the Genesis was the first time we interacted with Sega. Many peop...

Valkyrie Profile: Part 1

Since I started creating gaming content, I've promised myself and the few readers I have that I was going to be as honest as possible. I'm going to do that, even if it gets me in trouble. While I try to avoid really ridiculous hot takes, I'm going to absolutely call out games that I don't really like, even if they are otherwise popular. That goes for the popular selections for "hidden gems" or "underrated" games as well. I don't do it often, but I certainly have demonstrated that I have no problem doing it. I did it relatively recently with Yoshi's Island and I've done it in the past with other games like Alundra or Jet Grind Radio. Some of those games I've liked, just not as much as others. Some of them I have actively disliked despite how well regarded they are. Sometimes I get why these games are so beloved (I hated the controls in Yoshi's Island but my goodness is it beautiful and unique). Other times, I don't (Alundra is...

Castlevania: Harmony of Dissonance

It's time to keep the GBA Metroidvania train rolling. We started with Castlevania, then moved on to Metroid, and now it's time to make our way back to Dracula's castle. I was pleasantly surprised last year when I, sort of on a whim, decided to take a shot at Castlevania: Circle of the Moon on the Game Boy Advance. I had heard good things about the handheld titles in the series, but never actually took the time to play any of them. And that's a shame, because Circle of the Moon was outstanding. It was truly an exceptional example of just what the tiny but mighty GBA was capable of. It got me excited to dig into the other games in the genre I had missed from that console, both Metroid and Castlevania alike. I moved right along to Metroid: Zero Mission and while I wasn't as high on it as I was COTM, it was still a solid experience that was incredibly well designed and polished. So naturally, the next step in the progression was back to 'Vania with the next in that...